Under the Sea Part 1: K-19: The Widowmaker

The identity of the mysterious buyer of the Bond submarine has finally been revealed. Elon Musk, who became a billionaire from technology, bought the car-like sub at auction last month. To mark the occasion, (or to use it as a flimsy attempt to make something we were going to do anyway look current), we’re going to be looking at submarines in film. First up, the brilliantly titled K-19: The Widowmaker.

This is a true story about a soviet nuclear submarine in the 1960s. Captain Alexei Vostrikov (Harrison Ford) is brought in to replace the ship’s popular former captain Mikhail Polenin (Liam Neeson), who takes second place. Tensions run high between the two as the hapless crew lurch from crisis to crisis, born from their own collective incompetence.

Let’s first get the good stuff out of the way: this film looks great. The submarine exterior looks fantastic and the interior creates an incredibly claustrophobic feel. It’s also reasonably tense in places, in scenes where bad things happen or almost happen. Right, now the bad stuff.

Congratulations! You’ve been selected to serve aboard the Widowmaker!

It goes for the “foreign people speaking English with their country’s accent” approach which is a pet peeve of mine, particularly here as none of the cast can pull off a convincing Russian accent. It’s not helped by the fact that Neeson and Ford both have very distinctive voices that neither of them is actor enough to alter, so those familiar with their work will instinctively hear an Irish and American accent respectively. But they’re both awful too. Ford in particular falls down on all the “r” sounds, like his entire training for playing a Russian was watching Chekov in Star TrekNeeson, on the other hand, sounds like Colin Farrell with a hint of Rocky Balboa.

Not only does Ford fail with his accent, he also fails to inject any kind of humanity into his character, wearing the same, fixed, angry military expression for the entire film. The characters that aren’t these two are extremely peripheral, with most of the rest of the crew being indistinguishable from each other. The focus here is well and truly on the two big guys, which considering how two dimensional and underdeveloped they both are, really robs this film of an emotional anchor. The character ark of Vostrikov involves the tough and uncompromising captain seeing the error of his ways, but Ford’s performance, and his constant grumpy cat face, makes the guy seem like such an cantankerous old stick through the whole thing that it’s really hard to support him at any point. 

With the absence of real human drama, this film needs to compensate with a good plot or some juicy action, neither of which it delivers. Based on a true story, this feels constrained by its committment to events (although I hear it’s actually very inaccurate). The mission of the submarine was essentially an aborted one that fizzled out, which doesn’t necessarily make the best film. It could have worked if we cared about the people involved, or could take pleasure in watching them interact, but this is made impossible by the standard of writing and acting. It just never really goes anywhere.

Made in 2002, its melodramatic presentation and cheesy Russian accents make it feel like the kind of film that should have been left in the 90s. It’ll make you pray for the end of the Cold War just so Hollywood can start hiring actual Russians. But the Cold War ended in 1991, so there’s really no excuse.

This tidy looking action thriller has its moments, but is sunk by its poor casting and under written characters. A sub par sub flick.

Harrison Ford



3 responses to “Under the Sea Part 1: K-19: The Widowmaker

  1. Pingback: Under the Sea Part 5: Crimson Tide | Screen Goblin·

  2. Pingback: ExpendaBelle Watch: 10 Actors We’d Love to See | Screen Goblin·

  3. Pingback: Apocalypto | Screen Goblin·

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s